Plot Summary
Choir Giggling, Devil's Head
Sarah Jacobson, preacher's daughter in Devil's Head, Missouri, walks the line between parental devotion and budding rebellion. Her life is filled with church choirs, gentle rebellion—giggles in the pews with her best friend Heather—and growing curiosity about the big world beyond her rural boundaries. Her relationship with Matt, the golden boy, feels predestined but increasingly confining, even as family, church, and townsfolk expect them to be the perfect pair. Sarah's inner life is soundtracked by 80's pop, her desires and doubts stitched into every lyric. For now, she tries to be the perfect daughter, friend, and girlfriend, but temptation and change simmer just under the surface of her Sunday morning facade.
Easter Encounters and Old Flames
Easter Sunday brings home Isaac, Matt's older brother and the family black sheep, discharged from the army and oozing grown-up danger. His smirk is trouble incarnate; old childhood crushes are rekindled as adult heat. Sarah's attraction is immediate, amplified by Isaac's unfiltered irreverence, teasing, and challenge to everything she's been taught. Their banter is electric—gritty, flirtatious, occasionally crossing lines, and always layered with unspoken history. Isaac serves as both the devil's advocate and her forbidden fantasy, forcing Sarah to question her innocence, her limitations, and the meaning of goodness in her own life.
Cadbury Eggs and Temptation
After church, family dinners set the stage for subtle seductions: Isaac's playful defiance with a Cadbury egg during prayer, jokes about "Perfect Child" Matt, and a flask of booze sneaked into soda, which lands Sarah unexpectedly buzzed. Her tipsy bravado leads to awkward slips: grabbing the wrong brother's leg, causing blushes, awkward prayers, and new desires. The interplay is dangerous, wrapped in small-town manners and amplified by secrets. While Matt remains safe and predictable, Isaac is a living dare—a dare Sarah struggles to resist, her comfort and curiosity at war as summer unfolds with ever-heightening stakes.
Summer Jobs, Secret Dreams
Sarah is pushed into the family's plan: summer running the Corys' farm stand, rehearsing her role as future ranch wife. But this is at odds with her own musical ambition. Private moments—stolen in kitchens, choir lofts, or at midnight—reveal her yearning for something bigger than Devil's Head. The pressure to conform and people-please feels suffocating, especially with Matt's growing possessiveness, her family's financial reliance on the Corys, and the ever-present pull to Isaac, who alone seems to see her as more than a sweet Sunday girl.
Fumbling Condoms, Forbidden Crush
Prom night, with its breathless anticipation and careful rebellion, ends in frustrated attempts to lose her virginity with Matt. The awkward fumble—condom mishaps, forced passion, mutual fears—exposes the truth: sex isn't magical, and expectations crash. Meanwhile, Isaac makes his own moves—teasing, challenging, even helping when Sarah needs him most. The unspoken connection between Sarah and Isaac grows: in the aftermath of a failed first, Sarah's crush blossoms, her guilt deepening even as her longing shifts in ways she can't articulate, making her question if what's safe is what she truly wants.
Prom Night, Unfulfilled Longing
After the awkward prom, Sarah's discontent grows. She feels the pressure to follow the prescribed path: marriage to Matt, life on the ranch, safe stability. But her heart isn't in it. Her passion is music, her real fantasies are about freedom, and her imagination is increasingly haunted by Isaac—a symbol of all the risks she fears and secretly craves. Amid small-town gossip and parental expectations, Sarah begins to realize that first love doesn't always mean forever, and that sometimes longing for more is the bravest thing you can admit.
Ache of First Love
Sarah and Matt's relationship stagnates: they're close, but their "firsts" are mostly for show, a security blanket neither wants to discard but can barely breathe under. Sarah is caught between comfort and curiosity, with Isaac always present as an alluring alternative. The more Matt tries to play the good boy, the more Sarah's desire for something less "safe" and more genuine rises. Every accidental touch, every stolen glance with Isaac builds the ache, and Sarah's internal conflict becomes an open wound, her yearning impossible to ignore.
Musical Awakening in the Barn
Isaac and Sarah find themselves alone in the barn—the place where boundaries fade. A simple request for guitar lessons becomes a profoundly intimate experience: Isaac guiding her hands, music blurring into touch and longing. The barn is both metaphor and refuge—a place she sheds her people-pleaser skin and discovers an authentic, sensual self she never knew existed. Here, the tension between them is not just emotional but physical, and their connection, rooted in music, shifts the balance of Sarah's heart, awakening a new hunger in both.
Siblings, Secrets, and Scandal
The web of secrets thickens: Sarah's family's financial dependence on the Corys, Matt's need for perfection, Isaac's complicated past, and gossip about affairs within both families. Sarah keeps the truth about Wesley Cory's adultery and Sarah's own deepening attachment to Isaac locked away, even as the moral foundations of the adult world around her begin to crumble in her eyes. Sibling dynamics—her sisters' rebellion, Matt's unspoken rage, Isaac's own divided loyalties—all echo the cycles of secrecy and denial that come to define every family meal and Sunday gathering.
Prairie Lust, Prairie Guilt
With Matt increasingly absent—emotionally and soon, physically—Sarah and Isaac drift closer, their meetings charged with risky touch and barely restrained desire. Their encounters are clandestine, a swirl of lust and guilt: writing names on bodies, risky trysts in sheds, and heated conversations that skirt the edges of confession and catastrophe. Both are acutely aware that crossing the line will shatter worlds, but their mutual need is undeniable. Sarah is forced to confront the price of longing—how much happiness, and heartbreak, she's willing to risk for what never felt like just a crush.
Nashville Offer, Family Lies
Stifled by small-town roles and newly emboldened by heartbreak and loss, Sarah takes the greatest risk yet: running away with Isaac to Nashville, the city of her musical dreams. Their escape is an explosion of freedom—exploring music clubs, stoking their passion, living for themselves for the first time. But happiness is brief and costly. News from home is devastating: tragedy strikes, forever altering the landscape of Sarah's friendships and family. As Sarah and Isaac experience both creative and erotic awakening, the cost of freedom—compared to the weight of their secrets—becomes inescapably clear.
Friends Lost, Futures Shaken
Sarah's world is rocked by her best friend Heather's sudden, tragic death in a car accident. The event leaves her unmoored—guilt-ridden for not being there, livid at fate and God, isolated from the crumbling support structures of family, church, and community. The loss exposes the superficiality of small-town comfort and the limits of religious platitudes. Isaac becomes her anchor, the only one who can share her grief—yet even this solace is fraught with taboo and the ache of survivor's guilt, as Sarah mourns not just her friend, but the innocence and certainty of her old life.
Shattering Grief, Shifting Love
Heather's funeral marks a breaking point: Sarah's family is fractured, her father unyielding, and her relationship with Matt irreparably broken after the truth of her and Isaac's affair leaks. The small town's collective grief and judgment both isolate and clarify: Sarah sees what must be left behind, and who she truly wants beside her. The cost of honesty—her father's anger, her family's pain, the condemnation from her community—is devastating, but with Isaac, Sarah glimpses a fragile but fierce new kind of love, defined by honesty, pain, and a shared struggle to heal.
Fallout and Finding Courage
Sarah faces the fallout of her choices head-on: banished from her home, she finds herself homeless, jobless, but determined to carve a future on her terms. The old power structures—parental, romantic, religious—lose their hold as she reclaims her voice. With her sisters as new confidantes, her first love as a painful but necessary loss, Sarah begins to believe not only in her right to pleasure and music but in the necessity of self-forgiveness and chosen family. Isaac, for his part, sacrifices family ties and land, all in pursuit of an authentic life and love with Sarah, proving their relationship can survive betrayal and exile.
Rodeo Runs and Home Truths
Sarah and Isaac spend the summer following the rodeo circuit, forging a life defined by precarious hope, music, and mutual healing. Encounters with their respective parents and siblings—marked by honest confrontation and sometimes painful truths—lead to hard-won clarity. Isaac's own family history unravels, revealing deep wounds, long-standing secrets, and complicated acts of forgiveness. As they travel, love matures into partnership, and Sarah realizes that, despite heartbreak and tragedy, she's stronger and more capable of building a life—and art—on her own terms.
Taking Nashville, Taking Risks
Sarah finally steps onto the Nashville stage—not in someone else's shadow, but as her own artist. Each performance is an act of defiance, a tribute to Heather and everything Sarah lost. Isaac stands at her side: bandmate, lover, muse. Their love, forged in fire and risk, is now illuminated by the meaning of survival—the ability to make art, to love hard, and to remain open even after devastation. Family rifts slowly begin to heal; grudges give way to acceptance. Instead of people-pleasing, Sarah redefines what it means to belong, embracing a chosen future, not an inherited role.
Choosing Self, Finding Home
A decade later, Sarah and Isaac's journey has come full circle. Their love, once the source of so much guilt and chaos, is settled, strong, and full of new life: a daughter with her own bold spirit, music pouring out into the world, and real reconciliation with the families they once thought would hate them forever. Heather's memory accompanies every performance—Sarah's true north—a reminder that survival means carrying both grief and hope, pain and joy. The story ends as it began, with laughter, song, and a deep, hard-earned belief in love—messy, imperfect, and entirely their own.
Analysis
Jewel E. Ann's Sunday Morning is, at heart, a wrenching and erotic bildungsroman—part rural coming-of-age, part small-town melodrama, always anchored by the emotional turmoil of a girl negotiating love, grief, sex, and faith in a world determined to keep her in a box. The novel does not shy from the real costs of rebellion: betrayal, exile, traumatic loss, and guilt are the price of stepping into authentic adulthood. Rather than romanticizing sin or purity, Ann reveals the gray space in which love, happiness, longing, and mistakes coexist, dissolving simplistic notions of "good" and "bad." The most radical lesson is that survival—of heartbreak, of tragedy, of family dysfunction—requires both self-forgiveness and the courage to assert one's own dreams. Music is more than a soundtrack; it's the language of longing and the crucible for change. The power of the story lies in its ability to show that the true coming-of-age is not in having sex, escaping home, or even finding love, but in learning to live bravely with the consequences of one's choices—and in the possibility of building a life (and art) from the ruins, for yourself and those you carry with you.
Review Summary
Sunday Morning is a widely praised forbidden romance set in 1985, following Sarah, a preacher's daughter, and Isaac, her boyfriend's older brother. Most readers adored the slow-burn chemistry, emotional depth, and nostalgic 80s atmosphere, frequently citing Isaac as a standout hero. Common critiques include wanting more of Isaac's POV, less religious content, and a rushed ending. Recurring themes include self-discovery, family expectations, and pursuing dreams. The book draws consistent comparisons to Footloose and A Star is Born, with an overall rating of 4.14 stars.
People Also Read
Characters
Sarah Jacobson
Sarah is the archetypal "good girl": preacher's daughter, small-town prodigy, and people-pleaser who quietly chafes against expectations. Raised to equate virtue with obedience, she feels immense pressure to be pure, devout, and loyal to her boyfriend Matt—all while her own secrets, musical ambitions, and lust for something real ferment within. Sarah's psychological journey is one of self-discovery through loss: sexual awakening, the traumatic death of her best friend, and finally exile from her family all serve to burn away her illusions. Her connection with Isaac transforms her from a girl boxed in by duty to a flawed, passionate, fiercely honest woman who risks everything for her own happiness, even at a steep cost to her safety and reputation.
Isaac Cory
Isaac is the town legend's "bad boy"—Matt's older brother, exiled by both family and community for past transgressions, cynicism, and his refusal to play by anyone's rules. But beneath his insouciance and sexual bravado lies a deep sense of shame, longing, and complex morality. Isaac knows the price of both betrayal and heroism, having sacrificed for his family and been cast aside for it. His attraction to Sarah is partly a rebellion against repression, partly a desire for an authentic connection he's never had. Isaac's psychological growth is marked by his willingness to resist temptation in order to protect Sarah, to help her find her voice, and to sacrifice all material claims for emotional honesty and love.
Matt Cory
Matt is the fair-haired, easygoing boyfriend everyone expects Sarah to marry: athletic, respectful, obedient, and set for a bright future. But this perfection is a prison for Matt, driving his fear of failure, his avoidance of risk, and his inability to fight for what he truly wants. The revelation of Sarah's betrayal and the unmasking of his own family's secrets leave him emotionally gutted, forced to reckon with pain, resentment, and the emptiness of a life lived for others' approval. His ultimate acceptance of loss, and willingness to walk away from Devil's Head, marks his entry into manhood—and a bittersweet relinquishing of first love.
Heather
Heather is Sarah's soul-sister—her confidante, co-conspirator, and moral compass outside of dogma. Heather's openness, humor, and willingness to challenge Sarah's beliefs help give Sarah the strength to break free, even as Heather is the anchor to her childhood. When Heather's death shatters Sarah's world, her memory becomes a guiding voice: both cautionary and encouraging, reminding Sarah to feel deeply, pursue her dreams, and survive as an act of courage. Heather transforms from collaborator to beloved ghost—her absence an enduring source of pain, resilience, and artistry for Sarah.
Violet Cory
Violet, Matt and Isaac's mother, is the quietly enduring matriarch—warm, practical, and fiercely loyal. She navigates her sons' rivalry, her husband's betrayals, and the family's unraveling with a mixture of grace, denial, and tenacity. Violet's attempts to arrange Sarah and Matt's match are partly attempts to hold the family together as the emotional center slowly disintegrates. In the aftermath of disaster, she models forgiveness—not as blind acceptance, but as pragmatic love, helping Sarah, Matt, and even Isaac find a place in her ever-fracturing, ever-reforming world.
Wesley Cory
Wesley is the third-generation rancher, stern father, and church elder carrying the weight of family legacy and his own secret failings. His public righteousness contrasts sharply with his private betrayals: an affair with a much younger woman leading to catastrophic consequences for everyone around him. Wesley's gruffness and generosity are both genuine and self-serving: he enables, manipulates, and ultimately loses control of the world he believed was his to command. His arc is one of reckoning and quiet collapse, the fallout of his secrets forcing all his children to claim their own lives.
Eve Jacobson
Eve, Sarah's younger sister, is a classic middle child: more openly rebellious and skeptical than Sarah, yet equally searching for identity and belonging. She is Sarah's first confessor, accomplice, and (eventually) inheritor of both family trauma and the courage to pursue her own wants. Eve represents the next wave of young women learning from, and sometimes struggling with, Sarah's choices and mistakes—her blend of cynicism, dark humor, and vulnerability demonstrating that liberation always comes at a cost.
Gabby Jacobson
Gabby, the family's baby, is a shrewd observer who seems compliant but quietly soaks up everything: the drama, grief, and hypocrisy of the adult world around her. She is often the voice of innocent honesty, asking the questions others avoid. Gabby's presence reflects the ways families evolve: her own future is partially shaped by the revelations and revolutions enacted by Sarah and Eve.
Brenda Swensen
Brenda is the object of Wesley Cory's infidelity and a flashpoint for the town's underlying hypocrisy about age, sexuality, and power. Her forbidden affair with Wesley is less romance than an expose of broken dreams and needs—ultimately ending in a tragic, accidental act that kills Sarah's friends and forces every character to confront their own capacity for sin and forgiveness.
Peter (Sarah's Father)
Peter is the small-town pastor—strict, proud, and desperate to preserve his daughters' purity and the family's fragile respectability. His world is crumbling: faith fails in the wake of real suffering, and authority is continually challenged by his daughters' growth. His inability to offer unconditional love without prerequisites or penitence is both his downfall and, later, the means by which reconciliation and grace—flawed and hard-won—slowly re-enter the family story.
Plot Devices
Duality of Innocence and Sin
This novel's engine is the conflict between innocence and temptation, perfectly embodied in Sarah and Isaac's dynamic. The use of musical motifs, song titles for chapters, and key scenes in churches and barns highlight the psychic war between sacred and sensual longing. The central dramatic device is the classic "good girl/bad boy" opposition, subverted by making both characters far more complex and vulnerable than stereotypes would suggest. Small-town morality, sexual awakening, and religious hypocrisy play against each other, setting up moments of forbidden romance, guilt, and ultimate liberation.
Coming-of-Age Through Loss
The emotional arc hinges on Sarah's progression from sheltered obedience to adult autonomy, set in motion by catastrophic loss—the death of her best friend and the rupture with her family. The narrative structure foreshadows this climactic trauma with smaller betrayals, awkward milestones, and the tension between longing for both belonging and escape. Time is marked by seasonal rituals—Easter, prom, summer jobs, funerals—each one ominously carrying echoes of change. The story harnesses the classic bildungsroman template but subverts it with layered trauma and realistic, if messy, healing.
Intergenerational Secrets and Cycles
Multiple generations' secrets—a father's affair, a cover-up, the wielding of money and land as power—function as both obstacles and black mirrors for Sarah. The fathers' and mothers' choices ripple outward, determining the financial and emotional security of the young; the siblings carry the burden and are ultimately released, not by heroics but by blunt confessions and the vulnerability to withstand the pain of honesty. This cyclical device becomes a means for both excusing and transcending personal failure.
Literary and Musical Allusion
Every major turning point is "scored" by a song relevant to that era or mood, acting as both thematic guidepost and emotional amplifier. Lyrics are referenced, sometimes sung, as a way to say what characters cannot—love, lust, grief, or rage. The novel's structure, foreshadowing, and sense of time all reflect the mixtape logic of a coming-of-age playlist: bangers for triumph, ballads for heartbreak, and requiems for loss. These allusions serve both as world-building and as a device for bridging the gap between feeling and expression.
Layers of Narrative Voice and POV
The book moves fluidly between first- and third-person perspectives, allowing intense emotional immediacy in scenes of trauma or sex, while also delivering thoughtful retrospection in moments of analysis, confession, or future projection. Epistolary notes, chapter epigraphs, and the shift to Isaac's POV in later chapters serve as meta-devices for voicing truths otherwise left implied, letting the reader feel both present and omniscient.
