Plot Summary
Loss and Unwanted Gifts
After the sudden death of her parents, Sullivan "Sully" Thomas discovers she's inherited a psychic gift from her mother: the ability to absorb memories and thoughts through touch. This unwanted power isolates her from her twin brother Sam and the world, intensifying her grief. Forced to leave Florida for Indiana, Sully and Sam move in with their enigmatic grandmother, Nonna, who offers them a place at a small university. The move is both a physical and emotional journey, as Sully struggles to reconcile her new reality, her fractured family, and the overwhelming burden of her gift. The chapter sets the tone of loss, alienation, and the hope for a fresh start, even as Sully feels haunted by memories—her own and those of others.
New Beginnings, Old Wounds
Sully and Sam arrive in the small town of Hillsborough, Indiana, greeted by Nonna's imposing home and the weight of family history. Sully's psychic abilities make every interaction fraught, especially as she senses the emotional distance growing between her and Sam. Nonna's presence is both comforting and mysterious, hinting at secrets about their family's past. As Sully tries to settle into her new environment, she's haunted by memories of her mother and the unresolved grief that lingers in every corner. The chapter explores the tension between the desire for normalcy and the inescapable pull of the supernatural, setting up the emotional stakes for Sully's journey.
The Party in the Woods
Sam convinces Sully to attend a local college party, hoping to draw her out of her shell. The event, set against the backdrop of the woods, quickly turns uncomfortable for Sully, who is overwhelmed by the thoughts and intentions of those around her. After a disturbing encounter with a predatory frat boy, Sully flees into the forest, seeking solace. There, she meets Declan Cain, a rugged, enigmatic man who is immune to her psychic touch—a first for Sully. Their instant connection is charged with curiosity and attraction, but also a sense of danger. This pivotal meeting marks the beginning of a relationship that will challenge everything Sully knows about herself and the world.
The Man She Can't Read
Sully is drawn to Declan, fascinated by his immunity to her gift and the sense of safety he provides. Their chemistry is undeniable, and a night spent together in Declan's cabin deepens their bond. For the first time since her parents' death, Sully feels seen and understood. Yet, Declan is haunted by his own secrets and warns Sully that he's not safe for her. Despite his warnings, Sully's curiosity and longing for connection override her fears. Their relationship becomes a refuge from the pain and chaos of Sully's life, but also a source of new questions and dangers.
A Dangerous Curiosity
The morning after her night with Declan, Sully returns to the woods to retrieve her lost phone and stumbles upon the mutilated body of a young woman. Traumatized, she reports the crime to the police, who immediately suspect Declan due to the body's proximity to his property and his troubled family history. The investigation dredges up old wounds for both Sully and Declan, threatening to tear them apart. Sully's psychic abilities offer her disturbing glimpses into the victim's final moments, deepening her sense of responsibility and fear. The chapter heightens the tension, as the line between human and monster blurs.
Blood in the Forest
Declan is brought in for questioning, his past and the mysterious deaths in his family casting suspicion on him. Sully, desperate to protect him, is forced to confront the secrets Nonna has kept about their family's supernatural legacy. Nonna reveals the tragic history connecting their families, including the death of Sully's grandfather during a hunting trip with Declan's father and Red, Declan's family friend. The revelation strains Sully and Declan's relationship, as both grapple with guilt, grief, and the fear that their connection is doomed by the past. Declan, believing he's a danger to Sully, pushes her away.
Suspicions and Secrets
Sully's world narrows as Sam becomes overprotective and Nonna remains evasive about the family's supernatural history. Sully's work at the local newspaper brings her closer to the ongoing investigation, and she uncovers a pattern of animal attacks and unsolved deaths in the area. Nonna finally confides in Sully about the family's psychic gifts, urging her not to repeat the mistakes of the past by pushing away those she loves. Armed with new understanding, Sully resolves to fight for her relationship with Declan, even as the threat in the woods grows more ominous.
Tornado and Transformation
A violent tornado strikes Hillsborough, trapping Sully in the woods near the site of the murders. Declan, sensing she's in danger, transforms into a bear—a secret he's kept hidden—and rescues her, revealing his true nature. In the safety of a storm cellar, Sully and Declan confront their secrets: her psychic abilities and his shapeshifting. Their mutual confessions forge a deeper bond, as they realize they are uniquely able to understand and accept each other. The storm outside mirrors the turmoil within, but together, they find a fragile peace and the courage to face what comes next.
Truths in the Cellar
In the aftermath of the tornado, Sully and Declan share an intimate night, both physically and emotionally. They discuss their traumatic pasts, the burdens of their gifts, and the possibility of a future together. Declan reveals the pain of losing his family and the isolation of being a shifter, while Sully opens up about her struggles with her psychic abilities. Their honesty and vulnerability allow them to begin healing, both individually and as a couple. The chapter is a turning point, as they choose to embrace their differences and support each other, despite the dangers that still lurk.
The Monster Among Them
As Sully and Declan grow closer, a new threat emerges: Red, Declan's longtime family friend, is revealed to be a supernatural predator who has been killing shifters and absorbing their powers. Red's monstrous transformation is rooted in the trauma and cannibalism he endured during the fateful hunting trip years ago. He kidnaps Sam and uses Sully as bait to lure Declan into a deadly confrontation. The revelation shatters any remaining illusions about the safety of their world, forcing Sully and Declan to confront the darkness within and around them.
Family Ties and Forgiveness
Sully escapes captivity and rescues Sam, reaffirming their sibling bond and healing the rift caused by grief and misunderstanding. Together, they race to warn Declan about Red's true nature and the danger he poses. Sully's determination to save both her brother and Declan is fueled by her newfound acceptance of her gift and her refusal to let fear dictate her life. The chapter explores themes of forgiveness—of oneself and others—and the power of family, both chosen and blood, to overcome even the darkest threats.
The Final Hunt
The climax unfolds in the heart of the forest, where Declan, in his bear form, faces off against the monstrous Red. Sully and Sam use fire and ingenuity to trap Red, exploiting his fear of flames. In a brutal battle, Declan manages to fatally wound Red, and Sully delivers the final blow, burning the creature's body and ending his reign of terror. The victory is hard-won, marked by loss, trauma, and the realization that evil can wear many faces. The chapter is a testament to courage, love, and the willingness to fight for those who matter most.
Fire and Freedom
With Red defeated, Sully, Declan, and Sam return to a semblance of normalcy, though the scars of their ordeal remain. Declan grapples with the loss of his last connection to his past, while Sully learns to control her psychic abilities and embrace her new life. The family—now including Declan—begins to heal, finding strength in their shared experiences and the love that has grown between them. The chapter is a quiet celebration of survival, resilience, and the promise of a future unburdened by fear.
Healing and Homecoming
One year later, Sully and Declan have built a life together in Hillsborough. Sully thrives at the Chronicle, using her gift to help others, while Declan finds peace running his family's shop and guiding tours in the woods. Sam, now part of Declan's business, brings laughter and lightness to their days. The wounds of the past have not disappeared, but they have been transformed into sources of strength and understanding. The family's acceptance of their supernatural heritage and each other marks the true homecoming.
Love That Endures
On the anniversary of their first date, Declan surprises Sully with a fishing trip—a symbol of their journey from trauma to trust. Their love, forged in adversity, is now a source of joy and stability. Sully's mastery of her gift and Declan's acceptance of his dual nature allow them to fully embrace each other and the life they've created. The story ends with a promise of enduring love, resilience, and the courage to face whatever comes next, together.
Analysis
A modern fable of trauma, acceptance, and the redemptive power of love"Bear with Me" reimagines the paranormal romance as a story about the scars we carry and the courage it takes to heal. Sully's psychic gift and Declan's shapeshifting are not just supernatural flourishes—they are metaphors for the isolating effects of grief, trauma, and difference. The novel explores how loss can fracture families and identities, but also how vulnerability and connection can lead to profound transformation. The true monster is not the supernatural, but the unchecked hunger for survival at any cost, embodied by Red. The story's resolution—rooted in forgiveness, self-acceptance, and the willingness to fight for love—offers a hopeful vision for readers navigating their own wounds. In a world that often feels dangerous and unpredictable, "Bear with Me" reminds us that healing is possible, and that the greatest strength lies in embracing both our wildness and our humanity.
Review Summary
Bear with Me receives mixed reviews, averaging 3.68/5. Readers praise the instant chemistry between Sully and Declan, the suspenseful mystery, and Sully's unique psychometry gift. Many appreciate the engaging paranormal elements, including bear-shifting and a compelling villain twist. However, the most common criticism is that the novella is too short and rushed, leaving subplots undeveloped—such as the grandmother's gift and the paranormal town setting. Reviewers frequently wish it had been expanded into a full-length novel to better develop the romance and world-building.
People Also Read
Characters
Sullivan "Sully" Thomas
Sully is the heart of the story—a young woman reeling from the loss of her parents and the sudden onset of psychic abilities that make every touch a potential invasion of memory and emotion. Her gift, inherited from her mother, isolates her from others, especially her twin brother Sam, and leaves her feeling alien and alone. Sully's journey is one of self-acceptance: learning to see her gift not as a curse, but as a unique part of her identity. Her relationship with Declan is transformative, offering her the first true respite from her psychic noise and a chance at genuine intimacy. Sully's courage, empathy, and determination drive the narrative, as she fights for love, family, and her own sense of belonging.
Declan Cain
Declan is a rugged, solitary man burdened by a tragic past and the secret of his shapeshifting nature. Orphaned after a disastrous hunting trip that claimed his parents and Sully's grandfather, Declan has lived on the fringes of society, haunted by guilt and the fear that he is a danger to others. His immunity to Sully's psychic touch makes him both a mystery and a refuge for her. Declan's arc is one of redemption and self-forgiveness, as he learns to accept his dual nature and open himself to love. His protective instincts, loyalty, and vulnerability make him a compelling counterpart to Sully, and their relationship is the emotional anchor of the story.
Sam Thomas
Sam is Sully's twin brother, struggling with his own grief and the changes in his sister. Outgoing and charming, Sam masks his pain with humor and bravado, but his deep love for Sully is evident in his fierce protectiveness. Their relationship is strained by Sully's withdrawal and secrets, but ultimately, Sam's loyalty and willingness to fight for his family help heal their bond. He provides much-needed levity and grounding, and his eventual acceptance of Sully's and Declan's supernatural realities is a testament to his adaptability and love.
Nonna (Suzanna Thomas)
Nonna is a complex figure—elegant, reserved, and deeply knowledgeable about the family's psychic legacy. Her own grief over the loss of her daughter and husband has made her cautious and sometimes distant, but she ultimately becomes a source of wisdom and support for Sully. Nonna's willingness to finally share the truth about their family's gifts and history is crucial to Sully's journey of self-acceptance. She embodies the themes of generational trauma, forgiveness, and the importance of facing the past to build a better future.
Red
Once a family friend and surrogate uncle to Declan, Red's descent into monstrosity is rooted in the trauma and cannibalism he endured during the fateful hunting trip. His transformation into a supernatural predator who kills shifters to absorb their powers is both horrifying and pitiable—a cautionary tale about the corrosive effects of guilt, isolation, and unchecked hunger. Red's betrayal is the catalyst for the story's climax, forcing Sully and Declan to confront the darkness within and around them.
The Murdered Girl
Though unnamed, the murdered girl Sully discovers in the woods is a haunting presence throughout the story. Her death is the spark that ignites the investigation, the suspicion cast on Declan, and the eventual revelation of Red's true nature. She represents the vulnerability of innocence and the high stakes of the supernatural world Sully and Declan inhabit.
Leroy
Leroy is Sully's boss at the Chronicle, a gruff but well-meaning figure who pushes her to investigate the strange happenings in Hillsborough. His skepticism and journalistic instincts provide a counterpoint to the supernatural elements of the story, grounding Sully in the realities of her new life and giving her a sense of purpose outside her family's legacy.
Hannah
Hannah is a fellow student and intern at the Chronicle, offering Sully friendship and support as she navigates her new environment. Her presence highlights Sully's struggle to connect with others and the importance of chosen family.
Chief T.J. Rickman
The local police chief, T.J. is a steadying force during the investigation, balancing suspicion with fairness. His history with Declan and the Cain family adds depth to the town's interconnected relationships and the weight of past tragedies.
Declan's Parents
Though deceased, Declan's parents loom large in his psyche, shaping his fears, guilt, and longing for connection. Their tragic deaths are the origin of Declan's isolation and the catalyst for his journey toward healing and love.
Plot Devices
Psychic Gifts and Shapeshifting
The story's central plot devices—Sully's psychic touch and Declan's ability to shift into a bear—serve as both literal and symbolic representations of the characters' inner struggles. Sully's gift isolates her, making intimacy painful and fraught, while Declan's shapeshifting is a source of shame and fear. Their mutual immunity—Sully can't read Declan, and he is drawn to her—creates a unique space for vulnerability and healing. These abilities drive the plot, deepen the emotional stakes, and provide a framework for exploring themes of otherness, acceptance, and the search for belonging.
Foreshadowing and Suspense
The narrative is structured around escalating tension and mystery, with early hints of something monstrous lurking in the woods and the unresolved trauma of the past. The discovery of the murdered girl, the pattern of animal attacks, and the suspicion cast on Declan all build suspense, keeping the reader guessing about the true nature of the threat. The gradual revelation of Red's transformation and motives is foreshadowed through memories, rumors, and Sully's psychic visions, culminating in a climactic confrontation that ties together the story's emotional and supernatural threads.
Dual Perspectives and Interwoven Timelines
The story alternates between Sully's and Declan's perspectives, allowing for a nuanced exploration of their inner lives and the ways their pasts intersect. Flashbacks, memories, and confessions reveal the hidden connections between families, the weight of generational trauma, and the possibility of redemption. This narrative structure deepens the emotional resonance and provides multiple angles on the central mysteries.
The Forest as Symbol and Setting
The woods surrounding Hillsborough are more than a backdrop—they are a living, breathing presence that reflects the characters' fears, desires, and transformations. The forest is a place of danger (the murders, Red's lair), but also of refuge (Declan's cabin, the clearing where love blossoms). It embodies the duality of the supernatural: both wild and nurturing, perilous and healing.
